Healthcare Cybersecurity

PHI Potentially Compromised in Atlantic Digestive Specialists Ransomware Attack

Somersworth, New Hampshire-based Atlantic Digestive Specialists is one of the latest healthcare organizations to report a ransomware attack that has potentially resulted in the protected health information of patients being accessed.

The ransomware attack was discovered on February 20, 2017 although a subsequent investigation revealed that the ransomware was installed on February 18. The infection took two days to resolve, during which time access to certain computer systems was limited. All traces of the ransomware were removed from its systems by February 22, 2017.

Atlantic Digestive Specialists hired a third-party cybersecurity firm to conduct a thorough investigation of the attack to determine how the infection occurred, the extent of the attack, and which files were potentially accessed by the attackers.

The investigation revealed files containing patients’ names, addresses, telephone numbers, medical record numbers, clinical and diagnostic information, health insurance details, and in some cases, Social Security numbers were encrypted.

The investigation uncovered no evidence to suggest any sensitive data were accessed or stolen by the attackers, and no reports have been received to suggest any patients’ protected health information has been misused. Since the possibility of data theft could not be ruled out with a high degree of certainty, all affected patients have been advised to be vigilant for signs of fraudulent activity. Out of an abundance of caution, patients have been offered credit monitoring services to protect them against identity theft and fraud.

Over the past few weeks, several small healthcare practices have been attacked with ransomware. While in most cases data have been recovered from backups and no ransom has been paid, the attacks have resulted in considerable disruption and sizable breach resolution costs.

Regular backups of data should be performed to ensure no ransom needs to be paid in the event of an attack and small healthcare organizations should consider augmenting their defenses against ransomware.

Since the majority of ransomware attacks occur via email, staff should be advised to exercise caution and not to open any email attachments from unknown senders, never to enable macros on emailed office documents, and to be wary of hyperlinks sent via email..

Information on how HIPAA Rules apply to ransomware attacks is available from the Department of Health and Human Services on this link.

The post PHI Potentially Compromised in Atlantic Digestive Specialists Ransomware Attack appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Unencrypted Portable Devices are a HIPAA Breach Waiting to Happen

This week, OCR announced a new settlement with a covered entity to resolve HIPAA violations discovered during the investigation of an impermissible disclosure of ePHI. The incident that sparked the investigation was the theft of an unencrypted laptop computer from the vehicle of a CardioNet employee.

This week has also seen two data breaches reported that have similarly involved the theft of portable devices. Earlier this week, Lifespan announced that a MacBook had been left in an employee’s vehicle from where it was stolen. The device was not encrypted and neither protected with a password. ePHI was accessible via the employee’s email account. More than 20,000 patients’ ePHI was potentially compromised.

The second incident involved a flash drive rather than a laptop. Western Health Screening (WHS), a Billings, MT-based provider of on-site blood screening services, announced that patients’ names, phone numbers, addresses and some Social Security numbers have been exposed. The data on the drive related to individuals who had undergone blood screening tests between 2008 and 2012.

A WHS employee was on route to a health fair in a WHS-owned vehicle on February 7, 2017 when the vehicle was stolen. The flash drive had been left in the van. In this case, the flash drive was password protected, although WHS determined on February 15, 2017 that encryption had not been used on the device. The theft was reported to law enforcement, but the vehicle and flash drive have not been recovered.

WHS has not received any reports suggesting data on the device have been accessed or used inappropriately, although an impermissible disclosure could not be ruled out.  In response to the incident, WHS has taken steps to enhance its procedures relating to the storage of sensitive data on mobile devices and employees have been retrained on safeguarding sensitive information. Individuals affected by the breach have also been offered credit monitoring and identity theft protection services out of an abundance of caution.

The CardioNet, Lifespan, and WHS breaches could all have been prevented if encryption had been used. If an encrypted device is lost or stolen, the incident does not need to be reported to OCR, patients do not need to be notified, and most importantly, patients’ ePHI will not be exposed if devices are lost or stolen.

While HIPAA Rules do not require encryption to be used to protect ePHI on portable storage devices, if the decision is taken not to use encryption, an equivalent safeguard must be used.

While the use of a strong password may prevent data being accessed by thieves, it would not be sufficient to prevent a determined individual from gaining access to a device. A strong password is therefore not a safeguard equivalent to encryption. OCR would determine the use of a password – rather than encryption – to be a violation of the HIPAA Security Rule.

The simple solution to ensure that ePHI is safeguarded is to use encryption (following NIST recommendations) on all portable devices used to store ePHI. While encryption carries a cost, it is likely to be much cheaper than an OCR fine. The decision not to encrypt data on portable storage devices ended up costing CardioNet $2.5 million.

The post Unencrypted Portable Devices are a HIPAA Breach Waiting to Happen appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

WebRoot AV Update Failure Causes Havoc: Windows System Files and EXE Files Quarantined

A Webroot AV update failure has caused havoc for thousands of customers. The antivirus solution identifies potentially malicious files and moves them to a quarantine folder where they can do no harm. However, an April 24 update saw swathes of critical files miscategorized as malicious. While the occasional false positives can be expected on occasion, in this case the error was severe.

The Webroot AV update failure resulted in hundreds of Windows system files being miscategorized, resulting in serious stability issues. Many users’ servers and PCs were crippled after the automatic update occurred. The problem did not only affect Windows files. Scores of signed executables and third-party apps were blocked and prevented from running.

The error affected all Windows versions and saw critical system files categorized as W32.Trojan.Gen. Those files were moved to Webroot’s quarantine folder after the April 24 update. Once the files were moved, users’ computers started to experience severe problems with many displaying errors. In some cases, the moving of system files to the quarantine folder caused computers to crash. In other cases, apps were prevented from running causing major disruption to businesses.

Webroot AV also started miscategorizing websites as malicious, preventing them from being accessed. One notable example was Facebook, which was categorized as a phishing website and was blocked. Bloomberg also had its website miscategorized as a phishing website.

The Webroot AV update failure was quickly identified and corrected. The problem occurred between 7PM and 9PM UTC, with the update live for just 13 minutes according to SwiftonSecurity. While the update was only available for under 15 minutes, many thousands of customers downloaded the update.

The extent of the problem became rapidly apparent. The company’s forum was swamped with complaints from customers and social media was awash with comments from frantic IT admins and MSPs that had started receiving huge numbers of support calls. Webroot worked rapidly to fix the issue and while the Facebook blocking problem has been fixed, many users are still experiencing problems.

Webroot issued a set of instructions that will allow customers to restore the quarantined files and prevent those files from being quarantined again, although the instructions will only help home edition users. Businesses using Webroot AV have yet to be provided with a fix to restore system files. Webroot is currently working to correct the problem on business clients’ systems and develop a universal fix for all of its clients.

Instructions to repair the issue on Webroot home editions was published on the Webroot community forums:

Customers Turn to Twitter to Express Their Frustration About Webroot AV Update Failure

Many users took to Twitter to express their frustration about the Webroot AV update failure. Bob Ripley (@M5_Driver) said “I seem to have installed a nasty Ransomware app. It’s called Webroot. They already have my money, should I contact the FBI?”

While many used humor, the frustration caused by the update was clear. @Limbaughnomicon said “This false positive issue is driving me insane. As an MSP, a true nightmare. No quarantine restores work. HELP!”

While many users were complaining that essential Windows system files had been nuked, that was far from the only problem. Many other files were also miscategorised. The update took many business apps out of action, causing considerable headaches and loss of revenue. @Davedevery said, “I work for a small software company, Webroot has targeted our EXE and is removing it from pcs. Is there anyway to do like a blanket exclusion.”

iSupportU tweeted, “@Webroot everything is breaking, money is flying out the window… where are you? I have been on hold 20+min.”

Splumlee said “This is taking out all of the MSPs. Specifically we are losing almost all .EXE files across all of our clients.”

The post WebRoot AV Update Failure Causes Havoc: Windows System Files and EXE Files Quarantined appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Cardiology Center of Acadiana Ransomware Attack Impacts 9,700 Patients

A recent Cardiology Center of Acadiana ransomware attack has resulted in the exposure of almost 9,700 patients’ protected health information. The ransomware attack occurred on February 7, 2017 and was discovered the following day.

The attackers targeted a server used by the Lafayette, LA-based cardiology practice and deployed ransomware, which encrypted a range of files containing patients’ names, dates of birth, addresses, billing information, clinical data, medical images and social security numbers.

Cardiology Center of Acadiana has not disclosed exactly how the attack occurred, nor the variant of ransomware used in the attack, although the breach report suggests the attackers utilized open external ports on the server. All external ports have now been closed to prevent future attacks and the cardiology center’s antivirus protections have been upgraded.

Cardiology Center of Acadiana has not received any reports suggesting patients’ PHI has been copied or misused, although all patients impacted by the incident have been advised to exercise caution in case the attackers were able to steal their PHI.

The breach report submitted to the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights indicates 9,681 patients were impacted.

A recent study published in JAMA Internal Medicine indicates larger healthcare organizations face a higher risk of experiencing data breaches, but when it comes to ransomware, healthcare organizations of all sizes are at risk.

So far in 2017, the following healthcare organizations have reported being attacked with ransomware:

Ashland Women’s Health

ABCD Pediatrics

Estill County Chiropractic

Urology Austin

Metropolitan Urology

Cosmetic Surgery Center

Steps to Take to Protect Against Ransomware Attacks

Unfortunately, there is no single cybersecurity solution that can be deployed to prevent ransomware attacks. The best approach is to adopt a layered approach to cybersecurity which should include an advanced firewall along with solutions to block the main attack vectors.

Anti-virus and anti-malware solutions should be implemented and malware definitions kept up to date, a spam filtering solution should be deployed that is capable of analyzing inbound emails and blocking email attachments that pose a threat. Web filter should also be considered to reduce the risk of attacks via exploit kits. Word Macros should also be blocked.

Ransomware will typically run in the app data and local app data folders. Many cybersecurity solutions prevent ransomware from being executed in these folders if downloaded. Ransomware typically requires access to a C2 server to allow data to be encrypted. An intrusion detection system (IDS) can be used to block those communications and prevent file encryption.

In addition to technical solutions, all users should receive security awareness training highlighting the risk of opening email attachments from unknown senders, running macros, or installing unauthorized software.

Steps should also be taken to reduce the impact of a ransomware attack. Regular backups should be performed to ensure data can always be recovered. User privileges should also be restricted as ransomware will gain access to the same resources as the user. Access to mapped network drives should therefore be restricted.

Most ransomware attacks are not targeted. Cybercriminals take advantage of vulnerabilities that have not been addressed to gain access to end points and servers. It is therefore important to ensure security patches are applied promptly and vulnerability scans are regularly performed.

The post Cardiology Center of Acadiana Ransomware Attack Impacts 9,700 Patients appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Poor Security Awareness Greatest Threat to Healthcare Data Security

A recent survey conducted by HIMSS Analytics for the 2017 Level 3 Healthcare Security Study has shown that the biggest concern regarding healthcare data security is a lack of employee security awareness.

The Level 3 Communications, Inc., sponsored survey was conducted on 125 healthcare IT executives and IT professionals, including directors, IT managers, IT security officers and other IT staff. The aim of the study was to provide insight into the main high level security concerns within the healthcare industry.

The majority of respondents – 85% – said they had education programs that taught employees to be more security aware, although that was not enough to ease concerns. A lack of employee security awareness was the top-rated concern, with more than 78% of respondents saying employee security awareness was one of the main concerns regarding exposure to threats.

Employees are considered the weakest link in the security chain and with good reason. As last month’s Healthcare Breach Barometer report from Protenus shows, insiders are the biggest cause of healthcare data breaches. In March 2017, 44% of reported healthcare data breaches were due to insiders – a mix of errors and deliberate breaches. While there are always going to be bad apples, all too frequently, mistakes are made that result in the door being opened to attackers.

Other key concerns were exposure from third-parties and partners, which was rated as a top concern by 69% of respondents. Securing BYOD and wireless devices was a major concern for 54% of respondents, while having a lack of actionable threat intelligence was a top concern for 39% of respondents.

When asked about the main barriers that hampered organizations’ attempts to develop a comprehensive security program, competing priorities was the main issue, closely followed by budgetary constraints, rated by 79% and 74% of respondents respectively. The impact to clinical workflows, employee awareness and training, and a lack of in-house expertise made up the top five.

The survey revealed the majority of organizations are using multiple risk mitigation practices, with 87% using remote access and secure access controls, 85% relying on security awareness programs for employees and 75% using security consulting services, vulnerability assessments and penetration tests to uncover potential weak points in their cybersecurity defences. Six out of ten organizations have now implemented next-generation firewalls and more than half of respondents have also implemented DDoS mitigation services (56%) and access cyber threat intelligence (55%).

When asked to rate their level of concern about experiencing a security breach in the next 12 months, only 1.6% of respondents said they had no concern at all. 36% said they had a high level of concern.

Chris Richter, ‎SVP, Global Security Services for Level 3, said “The security threats the healthcare industry is facing are real and they’re only increasing in volume and sophistication as bad actors continue to seek out coveted protected health information.”

Richter said it is important to foster and maintain a culture of security and to ensure employees receive regular security training, but additionally, “healthcare organizations should implement a security governance framework and appropriate technology controls.” Those controls should include “threat intelligence, DDoS mitigation and next generation firewalling and sandboxing.”

The post Poor Security Awareness Greatest Threat to Healthcare Data Security appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Ashland Women’s Health Reports Ransomware Attack

Since the start of 2016, cybercriminals have been increasingly turning to ransomware to attack healthcare organizations. Rather than attempting to steal the electronic protected health information of patients, malicious actors are blocking access to ePHI and are issuing ransom demands to restore access.

While large healthcare organizations such as MedStar Health are major targets for cybercriminals, healthcare organizations of all sizes are at risk of experiencing ransomware attacks, even small one-practitioner medical centers.

This week, one such practice has announced a ransomware attack has resulted in patients’ ePHI being encrypted. Ashland Women’s Health (AWH) is a small obstetrics and gynecology practice in Ashland, Kentucky. Earlier this month, AWH submitted a report of a hacking/IT incident to the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights. The breach report indicates 19,727 patients were impacted.

This week, further information on the security breach has been released. The security breach was caused by a malicious actor who gained access to the computer system used by AWH and installed a ransomware variant called HakunaMatata. HakunaMatata ransomware is a variant of NMoreira ransomware.

While electronic protected health information was encrypted by the ransomware, a ransom payment was not made to regain access to data. AWH was able to recover all encrypted EHR data from backups.

The ransomware attack was reported to the FBI and law enforcement and an investigation is being conducted. AWH has now successfully restored patient data and has brought its systems back online. AWH experienced downtime of around two days following the attack while the infection was removed and data were restored. During that time, medical services continued to be provided, with staff resorting to pen and paper to record health information and schedule appointments.

In accordance with HIPAA Rules, breach notification letters will shortly be sent to all affected patients.

The post Ashland Women’s Health Reports Ransomware Attack appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Virus Infection at Erie County Medical Center Forces Computer System Shutdown

A computer virus sent via email to staff at Erie County Medical Center in Buffalo, New York – the main teaching hospital used by the University of Buffalo – has forced the hospital to shut down its entire computer system, parts of which remain out of action three days later.

The incident occurred in the early hours of Sunday morning. IT staff reacted promptly and shut down email and took the entire computer system offline as a precaution to prevent the spread of the virus. The IT team, assisted by external security experts, is working to systematically restore its systems. That process is expected to take several days, although most computer systems at the hospital have now been brought back online. The hospital’s email system is still not operational and its website is still inaccessible. The hospital has a backup of all data, including patients’ health information. A full recovery is therefore expected.

Staff at the hospital have been forced to temporarily work with pen and paper while the IT security incident is resolved. Communication between care teams has continued using ECMC’s proprietary text messaging system. A spokesperson for the hospital says operations are continuing as normal and patient services have not been affected.

Peter K. Cutler, ECMC’s Vice President of Communications and External Affairs, said “We have concerns about the motivation that led to this virus, and we are working with the appropriate agencies to determine the validity of whatever information we’ve received as a result of this virus coming into our system.”

The hospital is “confident that no patient information has been compromised,” however, at this stage, that cannot be entirely ruled out. The investigation into the attack is continuing and once systems have been restored, ECMC will be conducting a complete post-infection analysis to ensure that no further malware or viruses remain on its system. Law enforcement agencies, including the FBI, have been notified of the cyberattack.

The nature of the virus has not been disclosed, although the incident bears the hallmarks of a ransomware infection. Targeted ransomware attacks on hospitals are occurring, with at least one malicious actor using Philadelphia ransomware to attack hospitals and encrypt data. Those attacks started in the third week of March.

A decryptor has been released to unlock files encrypted by Philadelphia ransomware, although many ransomware variants have yet to be cracked. Decrypting data is only possible if a ransom is paid, something the FBI and other law enforcement agencies strongly advise against.

In order to ensure a complete recovery from a ransomware attack is possible, healthcare organizations must regularly backup their data and test those backups to make sure data can be recovered in the event of a disaster.

The post Virus Infection at Erie County Medical Center Forces Computer System Shutdown appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Healthcare Organizations Targeted with New Ransomware Campaign

Two hospitals have been attacked and had their files encrypted by Philadelphia ransomware. The latest campaign appears to be targeting hospitals in the United States.

Philadelphia ransomware is a form of Stampedo ransomware that was first identified last fall. The new ransomware variant is not particularly sophisticated and a free decryptor does exist (Available from Emisoft); however, a successful attack is likely to prove costly to resolve and has potential to cause considerable disruption. An attack may even warrant HIPAA breach notifications to be sent to patients if ePHI is encrypted.

The ransomware variant has been made available under an affiliate model and amateur attacks are being conducted. Brian Krebs recently found an online video promoting the ransomware variant highlighting its features and its potential for customization. The video claims that Philadelphia ransomware is the most advanced and customizable ransomware variant available.

Any would-be attacker can rent the ransomware by paying a one-off fee of $400 to the authors. After the fee is paid, the ransomware can be customized and used for personal campaigns.

At least one individual is conducting attacks on healthcare organizations, according to Forcepoint. Its researchers detected a campaign that uses a malicious DOCX file to download the ransomware. In this case, the Word document was not attached to a spam email, instead a malicious link was sent in a spear phishing email. Clicking the link triggers a download of a malicious DOCX file.

If the user opens that file they will be presented with three icons. Clicking any of those icons will launch malicious JavaScript that will download Philadelphia ransomware onto the device. The ransom currently demanded per infected device is 0.3 Bitcoin – approximately $364.

The attacker has used a variety of techniques to improve the chances of the icons being clicked. Spear phishing emails are sent to individuals within a targeted healthcare organization. The Word document contains the health organization’s logo along with the name of a physician at the hospital. The icons in the Word document appear to link to patient information contained in the file.

Forcepoint analyzed the JavaScript and detected a string called hospitalspam. A directory on the C2 also contained a folder with the same name, suggesting the attacker is targeting U.S. hospitals. Two hospitals in the U.S. have already fallen victim to a Philadelphia ransomware attack. Forcepoint reports that one hospital in Oregon and another in Southwestern Washington have been infected. The campaign appears to have started in the third week of March.

The discovery shows malicious actors are actively targeting the healthcare sector and further attacks are likely.

Recovery from a Philadelphia ransomware attack is a fairly straightforward process; however, the rise in popularity of ransomware-as-a-service could see healthcare organizations targeted more heavily over the coming months. Other ransomware variants may not prove so easy to remove.

Hospitals and other healthcare organizations should ensure they have implemented defenses against ransomware attacks, developed a disaster response plan specifically for ransomware attacks and have effective backup policies in place.

The post Healthcare Organizations Targeted with New Ransomware Campaign appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

2017 Shaping Up to Be Another Record-Breaking Year for Healthcare Data Breaches

2016 was a particularly bad year for healthcare data breaches. More data breaches were reported than in any other year since the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights started publishing healthcare data breach summaries in 2009.

In 2016, 329 breaches of more than 500 records were reported to the Office for Civil Rights and 16,655,952 healthcare records were exposed or stolen.

2017 looks set to be another record breaking year for healthcare data breaches. Figures for the first quarter of 2017 show data breaches have increased, with rises in theft incidents, hacks and unauthorized disclosures.

By the end of Q1, 2016, 64 breaches of more than 500 records had been reported to OCR and 3,529,759 had been exposed or stolen.

Between January 1, 2017 and March 31, 2017, OCR received 79 data breach reports from HIPAA covered entities and business associates. Those breaches have resulted in the theft or exposure of 1,713,591 healthcare records.

While fewer individuals have been impacted by healthcare data breaches than in the equivalent period last year, the number of reported breaches has increased by more than 23%.

Hacking incidents have increased by 26%, unauthorized access and disclosures have risen by 28%, and theft incidents have increased by 30%. Incidents involving improper disposal of PHI have remained the same and there has been little change in the number of reported loss incidents.

April has also started poorly, with Ashland Women’s Health having discovered a hacking incident that has resulted in the exposure of 19,727 patient health records.

While hacking incidents have risen year on year, the biggest threat comes from within. Protenus reports that in January, 59.2% of healthcare data breaches were caused by insiders, with February’s healthcare data breach report indicating insiders were responsible for 58% of breaches.

Largest Healthcare Data Breaches in Q1, 2017

 

Organization Covered Entity Type Type of Breach Individuals Affected
Commonwealth Health Corporation Healthcare Provider Theft 697,800
Urology Austin, PLLC Healthcare Provider Hacking/IT Incident 279,663
VisionQuest Eyecare Healthcare Provider Hacking/IT Incident 85,995
Washington University School of Medicine Healthcare Provider Hacking/IT Incident 80,270
Emory Healthcare Healthcare Provider Hacking/IT Incident 79,930
Stephenville Medical & Surgical Clinic Healthcare Provider Unauthorized Access/Disclosure 75,000
Primary Care Specialists, Inc. Healthcare Provider Hacking/IT Incident 65,000
ABCD Pediatrics, P.A. Healthcare Provider Hacking/IT Incident 55,447
WellCare Health Plans, Inc. Health Plan Hacking/IT Incident 24,809
Denton Heart Group Healthcare Provider Theft 21,665

The post 2017 Shaping Up to Be Another Record-Breaking Year for Healthcare Data Breaches appeared first on HIPAA Journal.