HIPAA Compliance News

Is a HIPAA Violation Grounds for Termination?

Is a HIPAA violation grounds for termination? What actions are healthcare organizations likely to take if they discover an employee has violated HIPAA Rules?

Since the introduction of the HIPAA Enforcement Rule, the HHS’ Office for Civil Rights has been able to pursue financial penalties for HIPAA violations. Organizations discovered to have violated HIPAA Rules or failed to have implemented policies and procedures in line with HIPAA Rules can face severe financial penalties. But what about individual employees who accidentally or deliberately violate HIPAA and patient privacy?

Do Most Healthcare Organizations Consider a HIPAA Violation Grounds for Termination?

Not all HIPAA violations are equal, although any violation of HIPAA Rules is a serious matter that warrants investigation and action by healthcare organizations.

When a HIPAA violation is reported – by an employee, colleague or patient – healthcare organizations will investigate the incident and will attempt to determine whether HIPAA laws were violated, and if so, how the violation occurred, the implications for patients whose privacy has been violated, potential legal issues arising from the violation and possible action by regulators. Healthcare organizations will be keen to take action to ensure that similar violations are prevented in the future.

When an employee is discovered to have knowingly or unknowingly violated HIPAA Rules there are likely to be repercussions for the individual concerned.

An unintentional acquisition, access, or use of protected health information by a workforce member in which the acquisition, access, or use was made in good faith and within the scope of authority would not be a reportable breach and may not necessarily result in disciplinary action.

Some healthcare organizations have strict rules on violations of HIPAA Rules and regularly terminate employees for HIPAA violations. Others have a policy of dealing with minor HIPAA violations internally. Depending on the nature of the violation, the incident may warrant disciplinary action against the individual concerned which could see the employee suspended pending an investigation. Termination for a HIPAA violation is a possible outcome.

Ultimately the repercussions for a HIPAA violation will depend on the polices in place at an organization and the severity of the violation. A violation of the Minimum Necessary Information Standard may, depending on the circumstances, be considered a matter for internal disciplinary action and not termination. Viewing the medical records of any patient without authorization is likely to result in termination unless the incident is reported quickly, no harm was caused to the patient, and access was accidental or made in good faith.

Recent Cases Where Healthcare Providers Deemed a HIPAA Violation Grounds for Termination

Criminal Penalties for HIPAA Violations

Termination may not be the worst that can happen when HIPAA Rules are violated by employees. Healthcare employees may be found criminally liable for HIPAA violations and cases can be referred to the Department of Justice for prosecution.

Criminal violations of HIPAA Rules can result in financial penalties and jail time for healthcare employees. A fine of up to $50,000 and one year in jail is possible when PHI is knowingly obtained and impermissibly disclosed. A fine of up to $100,000 and five years in jail is possible for violations involving false pretenses, and a fine of up to $250,000 and up to 10 years in jail is possible when HIPAA Rules have been violated for malicious reasons or for personal gain. A further 2 years can be added onto the sentence for aggravated identity theft.

The post Is a HIPAA Violation Grounds for Termination? appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Is Google Calendar HIPAA Compliant?

Is Google Calendar HIPAA compliant? Can the time management and calendar scheduling service be used by healthcare organizations or would use of the service be considered a violation of HIPAA Rules? This post explores whether Google supports HIPAA compliance for the Google Calendar service.  

Google Calendar was launched in 2006 and is part of Google’s G Suite of products and services. Google Calendar could potentially be used for scheduling appointments, which may require protected health information to be added.

Uploading any protected health information to the cloud is not permitted by the HIPAA Privacy Rule unless certain HIPAA requirements have first been satisfied.

A risk analysis must be conducted to assess potential risks to the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of ePHI. Risks must be subjected to a HIPAA-compliant risk management process and reduced to an acceptable level. Access controls must be implemented to ensure that ePHI can only be viewed by authorized individuals, appropriate security controls must be in place to prevent unauthorized disclosures, and an audit trail must be maintained.

Further, healthcare organizations covered by HIPAA Rules are required to enter into a HIPAA-compliant business associate agreement with any vendor before any electronic protected health information is disclosed, even if the service provider says it does not access customer data.

Google has appropriate security controls in place to protect data uploaded to Google Calendar and access and audit controls can be configured, so Google Calendar HIPAA compliance hinges on whether Google is willing to enter into a business associate agreement with HIPAA-covered entities or their business associates.

Google’s Business Associate Agreement

Google is willing to sign a business associate agreement with healthcare organizations for its paid services, but not for any of its free services. The business associate agreement covers the use of G Suite, and includes Google Calendar, Google Drive, the chat messaging feature of Google Hangouts, Hangouts Meet, Google Keep, Google Cloud Search, Google Sites, Jamboard, and Google Vault services.

HIPAA-covered entities must enter into a BAA with Google prior to any of the above services being used with ePHI. Once a signed BAA has been obtained the services can be used, although it is the responsibility of the covered entity to ensure that the services are used in a manner compliant with HIPAA Rules. Google provides a HIPAA-compliant service, but it is still possible for organizations and employees to violate HIPAA Rules using its services.

Is Google Calendar HIPAA Compliant?

So, is Google Calendar HIPAA compliant? Provided a BAA has been obtained, Google Calendar can be considered a HIPAA compliant time management and calendar scheduling service.

The post Is Google Calendar HIPAA Compliant? appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

EmblemHealth Fined $575,000 by NY Attorney General for HIPAA Breach

A 2016 mailing error by EmblemHealth that saw the Health Insurance Claim Numbers of 81,122 plan members printed on the outside of envelopes has resulted in a $575,000 settlement with the New York Attorney General.

While all mailings include a unique patient identifier on the envelope, in this case the potential for harm was considerable as Health Insurance Claim numbers are formed using the Social Security numbers of plan members.

Announcing the settlement, New York Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman explained that Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) Rules require HIPAA covered entities to implement administrative, physical, and technical safeguards to ensure the confidentiality of patients’ and plan members’ protected health information.

The error that saw Social Security numbers exposed violated HIPAA Rules. EmblemHealth failed to comply with “many standards and procedural specifications” required by HIPAA. Attorney General Schneiderman also said that printing Social Security numbers on the outside of envelopes violated New York General Business Law § 399-ddd(2)(e).

In addition to the $575,000 settlement, EmblemHealth is required to adopt a robust corrective action plan that requires a comprehensive risk analysis to be conducted related to the mailing of policy documents. The results of that risk analysis must be reported to the Attorney General’s office within 180 days. Policies and procedures related to mailings must also be reviewed and updated based on the findings of the risk analysis.

EmblemHealth must catalogue, review, and monitor mailings and ensure that all employees involved in mailings receive appropriate training. They must also be instructed to report any violations of the HIPAA Minimum Necessary Standard to EmblemHealth officials to allow prompt action to be taken manage risks to plan members. EmblemHealth is also required to report all security incidents to the Attorney General’s office for a period of 3 years from the date of the settlement.

According to Attorney General Schneiderman, New York has “weak and outdated security laws” which he has attempted to address by introducing the ‘Stop Hacks and Improve Electronic Data Security (SHIELD) Act’ in November 2017. There will now be a further push to get the SHIELD Act passed. Schneiderman claims the SHIELD Act will improve protections for state residents. Businesses will also be held accountable for data breaches that result in customers’ personal data being exposed.

“The careless handling of social security numbers is never acceptable,” said Attorney General Schneiderman. “New Yorkers need to be able to trust that companies entrusted with their private information will guard it appropriately. This starts with good governance—which is why my office will continue to push for stronger security laws and hold businesses accountable for protecting their customers’ personal data.”

The post EmblemHealth Fined $575,000 by NY Attorney General for HIPAA Breach appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

What is HIPAA Certification?

A frequently asked question in the healthcare industry is what is HIPAA certification; for although there is no standard or implementation specification within HIPAA that requires Covered Entities or Business Associate to certify compliance, several third-party organizations offer HIPAA certification services.

What is HIPAA Certification?

Although there is no official HHS-mandated HIPAA certification process or accreditation, it would be beneficial if there was. A HIPAA compliance certification could demonstrate that a Covered Entity or Business Associate understands and complies with HIPPA regulations – thus, for example, saving Covered Entities a considerable amount of time conducting due diligence on prospective vendors.

Nonetheless, despite there being no requirement for HIPAA certification, some companies claim to be certified as HIPAA compliant. What this means is they have passed a third-party organization´s HIPAA compliance program and implemented mechanisms to maintain compliance. In the absence of a program endorsed by the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), this is the next best thing.

Why there is No HHS-Endorsed HIPAA Certification

The Department of Health and Human Services does not endorse any type of HIPAA certification because HIPAA compliance is an on-going progress. A HIPAA certified company may have passed a third-party organization´s HIPAA compliance program and implemented mechanisms to maintain compliance, but that is no guarantee the company will remain HIPAA compliant in the future.

There are multiple reasons why a company may not remain HIPAA compliant in the future. It may change the technologies it uses or the ways in which technologies are used. It may change business objectives, operational procedures, or change staff management policies. Any of these changes might invalidate a HIPAA certification – notwithstanding that HIPAA regulations may also change in the future.

HIPAA Training and Certification

HIPAA does not require employees to complete any specific training program and obtain HIPAA certification. However it is necessary for HIPAA training to be provided “as necessary and appropriate for members of the workforce to carry out their functions.” It is also necessary for the date and nature of the training to be documented, and the documentation maintained for at least six years.

Since HIPAA Rules are complex and far-reaching, HIPAA training companies are often used as an alternative to in-house training. The training companies employ HIPAA compliance experts to train employees on the aspects of HIPAA relevant to their roles – such as the correct ways of handling protected health information (PHI), and allowable uses and disclosures of PHI.

One of the benefits to Covered Entities of using a third-party HIPAA training company is that, at the successful conclusion to a training course, they are issued with a HIPAA certification to verify and validate that employees have attended a HIPAA training course. While the certification may not be endorsed by the HHS, it will be beneficial to the Covered Entity in the event of a HIPAA audit.

Third Party Audits Confirming HIPAA Compliance

With regards to HIPAA audits, it is important to note the HHS states on its website that “Certifications do not absolve Covered Entities of their legal obligations under the Security Rule. Moreover, performance of a “certification” by an external organization does not preclude HHS from subsequently finding a security violation.”

Nonetheless, it is common for potential Business Associates of HIPAA Covered Entities to undergo audits by third party HIPAA compliance experts in order to confirm that their products, services, policies, and procedures meet HIPAA standards. The audits are useful for Covered Entities´ peace of mind as they confirm HIPAA compliance at the time the audit was conducted.

However, for Business Associates unfamiliar with the far-reaching complexities of HIPAA, it is likely they will require help to become compliant. For this reason, it can be important to select a third-party organization that not only offers HIPAA certification services, but one that can help Business Associates implement effective HIPAA compliance programs.

The post What is HIPAA Certification? appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

How to Report a HIPAA Violation Anonymously

One of the questions we are sometimes asked is how to report a HIPAA violation anonymously. This is because, in many cases, complaints and reports will not be reviewed or investigated without your contact details.

When you file a health information privacy complaint or a security rule violation complaint via the Office for Civil Rights´ (OCR) online Complaints Portal, the first page you are asked to complete is your name and contact details. The reason for this is because, if OCR reviews your complaint and decides to investigate it, the agency may want to contact you for further information.

You cannot go beyond the first page of the complaints process without entering any contact details; and, if you complete the form using fictitious contact details, OCR will be unable to contact you to obtain the information it needs to conduct an investigation. Consequently, it is not possible to report a HIPAA violation anonymously via the OCR Complaints Portal.

There are Other Ways of Filing a Complaint with OCR

The Complaints Portal is not the only way to file a complaint with OCR. You can download a complaint form, complete it, send it to OCR by mail or as an email attachment. The form allows you to deny consent for revealing your name or any identifying information – which is not the same as reporting a HIPAA violation anonymously and “may result in the closure of the investigation”.

You can also write anonymously to OCR, send an email from a disposable temporary email address, or call the agency directly on (800) 368-1019. If you find none of these approaches work because OCR does not want people to report a HIPAA violation anonymously, you could try one of OCR´s Regional Offices to see if one of these are willing to accept an anonymous report.

OCR is Not the Only Agency You Can Complain To

HHS´ Office for Civil Rights is not the only “enforcer” of HIPAA. Violations of the Administrative Requirements can be reported to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), violations of the Breach Notification Rule by organizations not covered by HIPAA can be reported to the Federal Trade Commission, and criminal violations can be reported to the Department of Justice.

All these agencies have complaints processes similar to OCR inasmuch as it is difficult to report a HIPAA violation anonymously. This is also usually the case with Offices of State Attorneys General. However, if you have a strong case for an investigation and explain why you are unwilling to reveal your identity, you may be able to report a HIPAA violation anonymously to a state agency.

How Else to Report a HIPAA Violation Anonymously

State and federal agencies are not the only bodies you can approach with a health information privacy complaint or a security rule violation complaint. You can also directly approach the organization responsible for the HIPAA violation. This gives you more options to report a HIPAA violation anonymously and a greater likelihood the violation you are reporting is addressed.

It is important to note that, unless the complaint involves a data breach subsequently reported to OCR by the organization, there will be no enforcement action taken by any state or federal agency. However, while there will be no record of an organization “getting into trouble” for failing to comply with HIPAA, your anonymous report may prevent somebody else experiencing an adverse event attributable to a privacy or security violation.

How to Report a HIPAA Violation Anonymously FAQs

Why doesn´t OCR want people to report a HIPAA violation anonymously?

Not only does it make it very difficult to investigate a privacy complaint without knowing who the complaint relates to, but malicious individuals could make unsubstantiated complaints that waste the time of both OCR investigators and the organization being investigated. By insisting on verifiable contact details, OCR can prevent malicious and unsubstantiated complaints – even though this requirement could dissuade some individuals from making justifiable complaints.

If I have to give my name, what protection do I have against retaliation?

§160.316 of the HIPAA Administrative Simplification Regulations prohibits Covered Entities and Business Associates from threatening, intimidating, coercing, harassing, discriminating against, or taking any retaliatory action against an individual who reports a HIPAA violation. This not only applies to patients and health plan members, but to any individual – including members of a Covered Entity´s or Business Associate´s workforce.

Can I report a HIPAA violation anonymously if the violation affects someone else?

Even if you are reporting a HIPAA violation on behalf of another person, OCR, CMS, the Federal Trade Commission, and Department of Justice will require your verifiable contact details to ensure the report is not malicious and unsubstantiated. You may be able to report a HIPAA violation anonymously to a State Attorney General´s office; but the best way to make a report anonymously is to approach the noncompliant organization directly.

How do I report a criminal violation of HIPAA anonymously to the Department of Justice?

Unlike some crime “tip lines”, the Department of Justice does not accept anonymous reports. The only route to reporting a criminal violation anonymously is to contact the noncompliant organization´s Privacy Officer who should investigate your complaint (subject to you having a strong case). If the Privacy Officer believes a criminal violation has occurred, they will report it to OCR, who will refer it to the Department of Justice for investigation.

What should I do if I complain anonymously to an organization, but nothing happens?

It may be difficult to know if your complaint to an organization has been ignored because the organization has no way of contacting you to explain what it is doing to correct the violation – which may take some time if it involves the development of new policies and additional workforce training. However, if you are certain your complaint has been ignored and it is still within 180 days of the violation being identified, you can escalate your complaint to OCR – albeit not anonymously.

Are HIPAA complaints anonymous?

Although you can request that your name is withheld when you make a complaint to OCR, complaints made anonymously will not be investigated. This not only applies to complaints made to OCR, but also to State Attorneys General, county HHS offices, and – where applicable – CMS, and the FTC. The option exists to phone an agency and make a complaint anonymously, but without your name, it is unlikely any further action will be taken.

The post How to Report a HIPAA Violation Anonymously appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Is Google Slides HIPAA Compliant?

Is Google Slides HIPAA compliant? Can Google Slides be used by healthcare organizations without violating HIPAA Rules? This post explores whether Google Slides is HIPAA compliant and whether it is possible to use the presentation editor in connection with electronic protected health information.

Google Slides is a presentation editor that allows users to create slide shows, training material, and project presentations. It is an ideal option for users who do not regularly create slide shows or presentations and do not have a software package that offers the same functionality. Google Slides is available free of charge for consumers to use and is equivalent to Microsoft’s PowerPoint.

Healthcare organizations that are looking to create training courses and slideshows that involve the use of data protected by HIPAA need to exercise caution. Use of Google Slides with electronic protected health information could potentially violate HIPAA Rules and patient privacy. That could all too easily result in a financial penalty.

Google Slides is a web-based presentation program that is not exempt from HIPAA under the HIPAA Conduit Exception Rule. The use of any ePHI with Google Slides is prohibited by the Privacy Rule unless healthcare organizations enter into a business associate agreement with Google prior to the use of Google Slides.

How to Make Google Slides HIPAA Compliant

The first step to take before using Google Slides in connection with any ePHI is to enter into a business associate agreement with Google. Google offers a BAA for healthcare organizations covering G Suite and Google Drive, which includes Google Docs, Google Sheets, Google Forms, and Google Slides.

As with all Google Drive services, it is essential to control who has access to files created on Google Drive. Healthcare organizations must ensure that any files created can only be accessed by individuals authorized to view the files and links to the files can only be shared with specific people. Sharing permissions should be carefully configured to prevent any accidental disclosures of ePHI.

It is important that no ePHI is included in the titles of any files created on Google Drive and third-party applications should be disabled. If applications need to be used, the security of those applications must be assessed and the developer’s documentation carefully checked. Third-party application developers would also be considered business associates and BAAs would be necessary.

Provided a BAA has been obtained from Google, Google Drive permissions are configured correctly, and best practices are followed, the Google Drive suite of products can be used by healthcare organizations in connection with ePHI.

The post Is Google Slides HIPAA Compliant? appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Is Google Forms HIPAA Compliant?

Google Forms is a convenient tool for creating surveys and gaining feedback from customers, but is it suitable for use by healthcare organizations? Is Google Forms HIPAA compliant or is its use likely to be a violation of HIPAA Rules?

Before any cloud-based service can be used by HIPAA covered entities or their business associates in connection with PHI, it is first necessary to enter into a business associate agreement with the service provider. Without a business associate agreement in place, use of the service would be considered a HIPAA violation.

Google and Business Associate Agreements with HIPAA Covered Entities

Google is prepared to enter into a business associate agreement with HIPAA covered entities and their business associates and offers its own BAA in which Google provides satisfactory assurances – as required by HIPAA – that the Privacy, Security, and Breach Notification Rule requirements will be followed. The BAA does not cover all Google services, but Google Drive – of which Google Forms is part – is covered by the BAA.

Obtaining a BAA from a service provider is only one part of the requirements of HIPAA. HIPAA covered entities and their business associates should also assess the security controls in place and should conduct a risk analysis to determine risks to the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of PHI. Any risks identified must be subjected to a risk management process and reduced to an appropriate and acceptable level.

The use of any cloud-based service is potentially risky, so care should be taken to ensure that appropriate controls are in place to prevent unauthorized access and disclosures. This is explained quite clearly in Google’s HIPAA Implementation Guide.

Google explains that care should be taken configuring the privacy settings of any elements of Google Drive (Forms, Docs, Sheets, and Slides) to limit the individuals who can access the data, which also applies when inserting Google Drive content into a website.

Is Google Forms HIPAA Compliant?

No software solution can be truly HIPAA compliant, as HIPAA compliance depends on the actions of users. However, Google does support HIPAA compliance and Google Forms is covered by its business associate agreement. Therefore, Google Forms can be considered a HIPAA compliant solution that is suitable for use in healthcare.

The post Is Google Forms HIPAA Compliant? appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Is Google Sheets HIPAA Compliant?

Is Google Sheets HIPAA compliant? Can HIPAA-covered entities use Google Sheets to create, view, or share spreadsheets containing identifiable protected health information or would using Google Sheets violate HIPAA Rules? In this post we assess whether Google Sheets supports HIPAA compliance. 

Under HIPAA Rules, healthcare organizations are required to implement safeguards to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of PHI. While it is straightforward to implement controls internally to keep data secure, oftentimes third parties are contracted to provide services that require access to PHI. They too must abide by HIPAA Rules covering privacy, security, and breach notifications.

A third-party that requires access to PHI – or copies of health data – to perform services on behalf of a covered entity is considered a business associate. A covered entity and business associate must enter into a contract – a business associate agreement – in which the business associate agrees to comply with certain aspects of the HIPAA Privacy, Security, and Breach Notification Rules. Without a business associate agreement in place, any sharing of PHI would be considered a HIPAA violation.

While Google does not look at the information uploaded to Google Sheets, since Google can potentially access the information, and data is stored on its servers, a business associate agreement would be required.

Will Google Sign a BAA with HIPAA Covered Entities for Google Sheets?

Google is committed to protecting the privacy of its customers’ data and ensuring all of its services are secure and data can always be accessed. Google is aware of the requirements of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act and the firm is prepared to enter into a business associate agreement with HIPAA covered entities for certain services.

Google offers a BAA for G Suite, which includes Google Drive. Google Sheets, Google Docs, Google Slides, and Google Forms are all part of Google Drive and are covered by the BAA.

Google explains in its terms and conditions that any HIPAA covered entity or business associate of a HIPAA covered entity that wishes to use G Suite in connection with any PHI must enter into a BAA with Google before any of its services are used in connection with PHI.

Is Google Sheets HIPAA Compliant?

Since Google offers a BAA, is Google Sheets HIPAA compliant? Google can be considered a HIPAA compliant service provider as Google supports HIPAA compliance for G Suite Basic, G Suite for Education, G Suite Business, and G Suite Enterprise domains and will enter into a BAA with healthcare customers.

Once a BAA has been obtained, it is the responsibility of the covered entity or business associate to ensure that Google Sheets and all other Google Drive and G Suite products and services are used correctly in a manner that does not violate HIPAA Rules.

The post Is Google Sheets HIPAA Compliant? appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Is IBM Cloud HIPAA Compliant?

Is IBM Cloud HIPAA compliant? Is the cloud platform suitable for healthcare organizations in the United States to host infrastructure, develop health applications and store files? In this post we assess whether the IBM Cloud supports HIPAA compliance and the platform’s suitability for use by healthcare organizations.

IBM offers a cloud platform to help organizations develop their mobile and web services, build native cloud apps, and host their infrastructure along with a wide range of cloud-based services for the capture, analysis, and processing of data.

The platform has already been adopted by many healthcare providers, payers, and health plans, and applications and portals have been developed to provide patients with better access to their health information.

IBM Cloud Security

IBM is a leader in the field of network and data security, and its expertise has meant its cloud platform is highly secure. Security is built into the core of all of the firm’s software and services to ensure that sensitive data remains confidential and cannot be accessed by unauthorized individuals. Its audit and security reports are made available to its clients to assess during risk analysis and risk management processes.

Business Associate Agreement for the IBM Cloud Platform

Since 2014, IBM has been offering its cloud services to healthcare clients and has been entering into business associate agreements for its social, mobile, meetings, and mail cloud offerings.

IBM’s business associate agreements covers the IBM Cloud and details its responsibilities for security, including technical and physical controls in its data centers, permitted uses and disclosures of PHI, use of subcontractors, and its reporting requirements in the event of a security breach.

Healthcare customers must ensure they have a signed copy of the business associate agreement from IBM before any IBM cloud services are used in conjunction with protected health information.

IBM also offers HIPAA covered entities and their business associates services to help them configure their cloud applications correctly and create appropriate privacy and security solutions.

Is the IBM Cloud HIPAA Compliant?

Is the IBM Cloud HIPAA compliant? IBM meets its responsibilities as a business associate by ensuring its cloud platform meets and exceeds the minimum requirements of the HIPAA Security Rule and IBM agrees to abide by the HIPAA Privacy Rule and Breach Notification Rule.

IBM will enter into a business associate agreement with HIPAA covered entities covering the IBM Cloud, So the IBM Cloud can be considered a HIPAA compliant cloud platform.

However, HIPAA compliance is a shared responsibility. IBM only provides the security and the tools to ensure its cloud platform can be used without violating HIPAA Rules. It is the responsibility of HIPAA-covered entities to ensure that cloud-based infrastructure and applications are not misconfigured, and that stored files are appropriately secured.

The post Is IBM Cloud HIPAA Compliant? appeared first on HIPAA Journal.