HIPAA Breach News

Two Maine Healthcare Providers Report Email Security Breaches Impacting 52,000 Patients

InterMed, one of the largest healthcare providers in Southern Maine, has discovered information on up to 30,000 patients has potentially been accessed by an unauthorized individual as a result of a recent email security breach.

On September 6, 2019, InterMed discovered an employee’s email account had been accessed by a third-party without authorization. An independent investigation into the breach revealed the account was compromised on September 4 and a further three employee email accounts were also found to have been compromised between September 7 and September 10, 2019.

Emails and attachments in the compromised accounts contained patient information such as names, dates of birth, clinical information, and health insurance information, and for 155 individuals, Social Security numbers. The breach was limited to email accounts. The electronic medical record system was not accessed. It was not possible to determine whether emails in the account were actually viewed.

The compromised email accounts were immediately secured, and affected patients were notified about the breach on November 5. Individuals whose Social Security number was potentially compromised are being offered complimentary credit monitoring and identity theft protection services. InterMed has said “we are enhancing our adherence to email best practices,” and strengthening security to protect against further attacks.

Sweetser Breach Impacts 22,000 Current and Former Clients

Another Maine healthcare organization has also recently announced an email system breach. Sweetser, a Saco, ME-based provider of mental health services, discovered a potential email account breach on June 24, 2019 when suspicious activity was identified in the account. Assisted by a digital forensics company, the breach was confirmed as affecting other employee email accounts, which were accessed by an unauthorized individual between June 18 and June 27, 2019.

Sweetser said it was informed on September 10, 2019 that one or more of the compromised email accounts contained patient information. The incident was reported to the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights on September 13, 2019 as affecting 22,000 patients. Sweetser announced the breach and started sending patient notification letters on October 25, 2019.

The types of information in the email accounts varied from patient to patient and may have included names, addresses, telephone numbers, dates of birth, health insurance information, Social Security numbers, identification numbers, drivers license numbers, Medicare/Medicaid information, payment/claims information, diagnosis codes, and information on patients’ medical conditions and treatments.

Individuals whose Social Security number was potentially compromised are being offered complimentary credit monitoring and identity theft protection services.

The post Two Maine Healthcare Providers Report Email Security Breaches Impacting 52,000 Patients appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Texas Health Resources Reports Data Breach Affecting 82,577 Patients

82,577 patients of Texas Health Resources have had some of their health information impermissibly disclosed as a result of a misconfiguration of its billing system.

Texas Health Resources is one of the largest faith-based health systems in the United States and the largest in North Texas, with facilities in 16 counties serving more than 7 million patients.

On August 23, 2019, Texas Health Resources learned that an error in its billing system had resulted in patient information being incorrectly matched with guarantors. The error caused mailings to be sent to incorrect patients or their guarantors. The error occurred on July 19, 2019 and affected mailings up to September 4, 2019.

An investigation was launched to determine which individuals had been affected and the types of patient information that had been impermissibly disclosed. The investigation revealed the following types of information were included in the mailings and had been sent to incorrect individuals: Name, service date, account number, names of treating physicians, name of health insurer, amount owed, and in some cases, a short description of the services received. Highly sensitive information such as Social Security numbers, financial information, and health insurance numbers were not involved. Affected individuals were notified by mail on October 22.

Texas Health Resources has taken steps to prevent similar errors from occurring in the future and has enhanced its data security procedures.

The impermissible disclosure has been reported to the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights in 15 separate breach reports, one for each of the facilities affected.

The affected hospitals are listed below:

Affected Hospitals Individuals Affected
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Fort Worth 14,881
Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Dallas 12,415
Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Plano 9,678
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Southwest Fort Worth 7,478
Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Denton 6,688
Texas Health Arlington Memorial 6,187
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Hurst-Euless-Bedford 4,804
Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Rockwall 4,789
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Alliance 3,784
Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Allen 2,993
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Cleburne 2,737
 Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Kaufman 2,157
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Azle 2,113
Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Stephenville 1,348
Texas Health Harris Methodist Southlake 525

Rosenbaum Dental Group Breach Notification Error Prompts Further Notifications

Florida-based Rosenbaum Dental Group discovered malware had been downloaded onto its systems that potentially gave unauthorized individuals access to the PHI of around 1,200 patients. Affected individuals were notified about the breach on July 1, 2019; however, the breach notifications issued to affected patients were sent on postcards rather than letters. That allowed individuals to be identified as patients of Rosenbaum Dental Group.

In a recent press release, Rosenbaum Dental Group issued an apology about the error and potential HIPAA breach and has confirmed that notification letters are now being sent to advise patients about the error. Affected individuals are being offered one year of complimentary credit monitoring services as a precaution.

The post Texas Health Resources Reports Data Breach Affecting 82,577 Patients appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Brooklyn Hospital Center Malware Attack Results in Loss of Patients’ Health Records

Brooklyn Hospital Center in New York has announced that a security breach occurred in late July 2019 that resulted in malware being installed on some of the hospital’s servers.

The attack was discovered promptly, and steps were taken to limit the harm caused; however, it was not possible to prevent certain files from being encrypted.

A third-party digital forensics firm was retained to assess the nature and extent of the malware attack and assist with the recovery of encrypted files. On September 4, following ‘exhaustive efforts’ to recover the encrypted files, it was determined that certain patient information was unrecoverable.

Entire medical records have not been lost, but some patients’ dental and cardiac images could not be restored. The hospital is currently conducting a review to determine which patients have been affected and those individuals will be notified in due course. As is often the case with ransomware attacks such as this, the goal of the attackers appears to have been to extort money from the hospital rather than gain access to patient information. No reports of misuse of patient information have been received and the forensic investigation uncovered no evidence to suggest the attackers accessed or exfiltrated patient information.

Brooklyn Hospital Center already had stringent security controls in place to prevent cyberattacks, although in this instance those controls were circumvented by the attackers. Policies, procedures, and existing security protocols are under review and security controls will be enhanced to prevent further breaches of this nature from occurring in the future.

Unauthorized PHI Access and Use Discovered by Washington University School of Medicine

Washington University School of Medicine (WUSM) has discovered an employee’s personal laptop computer was used by an unauthorized individual to access a WUSM email account which contained the protected health information of certain patients of the Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences.

The unauthorized individual, who had a personal relationship with the employee, accessed the email account between April 29, 2019 and September 3, 2019. A forensic investigation was conducted by a third-party firm to determine what information was contained in the account and could have been accessed. The investigation revealed information in emails and email attachments included patients’ names, medical record numbers, dates of birth, provider names, and limited treatment and clinical information, such as diagnoses and prescription information. The Social Security numbers and health insurance information of certain patients were also potentially compromised.

It was not possible to determine which emails and attachments had been opened, so the decision was taken to notify all individuals whose protected health information was potentially compromised. Any individual who had their Social Security number exposed has been offered complimentary credit monitoring and identity theft protection services.

The breach came to light on September 3, 2019 following reports that certain patients had been sent a letter about an employee of the Ophthalmology Department. The subsequent investigation led to the discovery of the security breach. It is unclear why those individuals were contacted.

WUSM has since implemented additional security enhancements and has re-educated employees on password best practices.

The incident has yet to appear on the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights’ breach portal, so it is currently unclear how many patients have been affected.

The post Brooklyn Hospital Center Malware Attack Results in Loss of Patients’ Health Records appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

California Mental Health Services Provider Discovers Unauthorized Email Account Access and File Deletion

The Guidance Center (TGC), a nonprofit provider of mental health care services to disadvantaged children and their families in Long Beach, Compton, San Pedro, and Avalon in California, has discovered a breach of its digital environment.

In a breach notification letter to the California Attorney General, Xavier Becerra, TGC’s counsel explained that unusual activity was detected within TGC’s digital environment in late March 2019. Staff had reported that files and backups appeared to be missing. An internal investigation was launched which concluded the files had been deleted. Further investigation also showed that a TGC computer had been reconfigured to allow it to be remotely accessed.

TGC believes the change to the computer and deletion of files was most likely the work of a former employee. The matter was reported to both the Long Beach Police Department and the FBI, and the individual suspected of the illegal access was sent a cease and desist letter by TGC’s attorney on March 30, 2019. Following that letter, all further unauthorized access stopped.

On April 19, 2019, TGC engaged a difficult forensics company to determine whether any patient information had been accessed without authorization. No evidence of unauthorized PHI access or data exfiltration was discovered; however, certain employee email accounts had been accessed remotely.

According to the substitute breach notification letter on the TGC website, TGC learned on September 19, 2019 that some sensitive information was contained in those email accounts. It took some time to determine which clients had been affected and to find up to date contact information for those individuals. Breach notification letters were sent on October 25, 2019.

In total, the protected health information of 1,235 current and former clients was detailed in the email accounts and could therefore have been accessed, although no evidence of unauthorized PHI access was discovered.

The information in the accounts was limited to names, addresses, dates of birth, health insurance/claims information, medical information and, for a limited number of patients, Social Security numbers.

All individuals whose Social Security number was exposed have been offered 12 months of complimentary credit monitoring services. Additional security controls have now been implemented to prevent any similar incidents from occurring in the future and the deleted files have been restored. No reason was given as to why the email accounts were accessed and files and backups were deleted.

The post California Mental Health Services Provider Discovers Unauthorized Email Account Access and File Deletion appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Utah Valley Eye Center Hacking Incident Leads to Phishing Attack on Patients

Utah Valley Eye Center in Provo, UT is warning patients that some of their personal information may have been accessed by an unauthorized individual following a security breach of its scheduling reminder portal on June 28, 2018.

The hacker obtained the email addresses of 5,764 patients and sent each a phishing email in an attempt to gain access to PayPal credentials. The emails spoofed PayPal and advised the recipients that they had received a payment.

Upon discovery of the security breach, Utah Valley Eye Center contacted all individuals who had been emailed to warn them about the security breach. No evidence has been uncovered to suggest any other information was accessed or misused, although the hacker would have had access to patient names, addresses, phone numbers, and dates of birth. No personal health or financial information is believed to have been accessed.

Only 5,764 phishing emails were sent, but Utah Valley Eye Center could not determine exactly how many patients had been affected by the breach. According to a recent press release, the demographic information of up to 20,000 patients may have been compromised, according to a recent report in the Daily Herald.

The incident has been reported to the Utah Department of Health, the Utah Department of Human Services, and the HHS. Affected individuals have been advised to place a fraud alert on their credit files as a precaution against misuse of their information.

It is currently unclear when the breach was discovered and why it has taken until now for a press release to be issued about the security breach.

The post Utah Valley Eye Center Hacking Incident Leads to Phishing Attack on Patients appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Prisma Health Website Breach Potentially Impacts 22,000 Individuals

Prisma Health Midlands is notifying approximately 19,000 patients and 3,000 employees about a data breach involving the Palmetto Health website.

Prisma Health – formerly Palmetto Health – learned on August 29, 2019 that an unauthorized individual had obtained the login credentials of a Prisma Health employee. Those credentials allowed the attacker to access the Palmetto Health website, which contained volunteer registration information and patient pre-registration forms that had been completed online.

Those forms related to 6 Midlands hospitals and contained information such as names, addresses, dates of birth, limited health information and, for certain individuals, their Social Security number. No medical records or financial information were exposed. Prisma Health was not able to determine for how long the credentials were accessible.

Upon discovery of the incident, the employee’s password was changed to prevent any further unauthorized access and policies and procedures are being updated to prevent similar breaches in the future. Affected individuals have been notified by mail and individuals whose Social Security number was exposed have been offered complimentary credit monitoring and identity theft protection services for 12 months.

Prisma Health has suffered multiple privacy breaches this year. In April, Prisma Health announced it had been the victim of a phishing attack that saw the email accounts of several employees accessed by an unauthorized individual. The PHI of 23,811 individuals was exposed as a result of the attack. A further privacy breach was announced in July when a notebook containing the PHI of OB/GYN patients from its Richland Campus in Columbia was discovered to have been stolen from a physician’s car. Information on up to 2,770 individuals was recorded in the notebook.

Seattle Cancer Care Alliance Email Error Exposed Patients’ Email Addresses

944 patients of Seattle Cancer Care Alliance (SCCA) have had their email addresses exposed to other patients as a result of an error by a member of staff when sending an August 27, 2019 email invitation.

Rather than adding email addresses to the blind carbon copy (BCC) field, thus shielding the recipients’ email addresses from each other, the email addresses were added to visible fields and could be seen by all individuals who received the email invitation. No other information was disclosed.

SCCA is now evaluating its systems, policies and procedures and safeguards will be implemented to prevent similar breaches in the future. Notification letters were sent to affected patients on October 16, 2019.

The post Prisma Health Website Breach Potentially Impacts 22,000 Individuals appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Quest Diagnostics $195,000 Class Action Settlement Approved by Federal Judge

Following a November 2016 cyberattack at Quest Diagnostics that resulted in an unauthorized individual accessing and stealing the personal information and medical test results of 34,000 individuals, a class action lawsuit was filed by the breach victims. Quest Diagnostics proposed a $195,000 settlement to resolve the case. The settlement has recently been approved by a U.S district court judge in New Jersey.

The types of information obtained by the hacker included names, phone numbers, dates of birth, and the results of medical tests, including HIV test results.

The lawsuit alleged Quest Diagnostics had violated New Jersey laws and had been negligent for failing to safeguard the sensitive health information of its clients, Quest Diagnostics had breached its contract with clients, and that the company failed to provide timely notifications to patients informing them about the hacking incident and theft of their data.

Quest Diagnostics maintains the claims are meritless, but the decision was taken to settle the lawsuit to avoid ongoing litigation and further legal costs. Under the terms of the settlement, all individuals who can demonstrate they have suffered monetary losses as a direct result of the breach will be entitled to claim $250. The payment is intended to compensate individuals for having to take action to secure their accounts and pay for credit monitoring and identity theft protection services.

Any individual whose HIV test results were included in the stolen data will be entitled to claim $75, in addition in the $250 if they have also suffered monetary losses.

Quest Diagnostics has also been named as a co-defendant in several lawsuits filed by victims of the data breach at American Medical Collection Agency (AMCA) earlier this year. The hacking of the AMCA payment portal enabled the attacker to steal the protected health information of more than 26 million individuals, 11,500,000 of whom had received medical tests at Quest Diagnostics and their PHI had been passed to AMCA for collection.

The post Quest Diagnostics $195,000 Class Action Settlement Approved by Federal Judge appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Improper Disposal Incident at Smith’s Food & Drug Affects Almost 58,000 Patients

Salt Lake City, OH-based Smith’s Food & Drug has announced that the pharmacy records of around 58,000 patients have been disposed of in an improper manner.

The improper disposal incident was discovered by the grocery and drug store chain on August 29, 2019 and affected customers of its store at 4600 East Sunset Road in Henderson, NV.

12 boxes of files containing physical pharmacy records, including prescriptions, were disposed of by a former associate in an improper manner. The records were not shredded, pulped, burned, or pulverized to render them unreadable, indecipherable, and ensure they could not otherwise be reconstructed, as is required by HIPAA. The boxes of files were put in the store’s trash compactor along with regular trash.

Since the records are no longer accessible, it was not possible to determine which patients were impacted and the exact types of information that had been exposed. Smith’s Food & Drug has estimated the sensitive information of approximately 57,600 patients was likely contained in the pharmacy records. The types of HIPAA-covered information in the records likely included the full names of patients, along with an address, phone number, date of birth, gender, prescription number, drug name, and third-party payor information. According to a statement issued by Smith’s Food & Drug, the records were 11 or more years old.

While it is unlikely that the records were viewed or obtained by unauthorized individuals, since the records were not disposed of in a secure manner, unauthorized access cannot be ruled out. Smith’s Food & Drug has not received any reports to suggest any patient information has been misused but has advised customers to review their explanation of benefits statements from their health plans and to report any medical services listed that have not been received.

Smith’s Food & Drug is re-educating select associates on company policies and HIPAA Rules concerning the disposal of sensitive information and additional safeguards are being implemented to prevent similar incidents in the future.  Smith’s Food & Drug has confirmed that the associate responsible has been terminated.

The post Improper Disposal Incident at Smith’s Food & Drug Affects Almost 58,000 Patients appeared first on HIPAA Journal.

Report Suggests Augmented Security Following a Data Breach Contributes to Increase in Patient Mortality Rate

Healthcare data breaches lead to a reduction in the quality of care provided to patients, according to a study recently published in Health Services Research.

Researchers analyzed data from Medicare Compare which details quality measures at hospitals. Data from 2012-2016 was analyzed and compared with data from the HHS’ Office for Civil Rights on data breaches of more than 500 records over the same period. The researchers analyzed data on 3,025 Medicare-certified hospitals, 311 of which had experienced a data breach.

According to the study, the time it took from a patient arriving at the hospital to an electrocardiogram being performed increased by up to 2.7 minutes at hospitals that had experienced a data breach. A ransomware attack that prevents clinicians from accessing patient data will limit their ability to provide essential medical services to patients, so a delay in conducting tests and obtaining the results is to be expected. However, the delays were found to continue for months and years after an cyberattack was experienced.

The study showed that 3-4 years after a breach had occurred there were still delays in providing electrocardiograms to patients. The waiting time for an electrocardiograms to patients was found to be up to 2 minutes longer than before the breach occurred.

Hospitals that experienced a data breach also saw an increase in the 30‐day acute myocardial infarction mortality rate. The mortality rate at breached hospitals increased by as much as 0.36%.

The increase in mortality rate has not been attributed to the cyberattack itself, as recovery is usually possible without a few days to a few weeks after a cyberattack. The researchers suggest the delays in providing medical services following a cyberattack is due to the steps hospitals have taken to improve the security of their systems and better protect patient data, along with the increased HHS oversight that occurs after a data breach is experienced. These factors can result in a deterioration in the timeliness of care and patient outcomes.

Following a cyberattack, hospitals augment their security controls to prevent further cyberattacks from succeeding. Those measures include multi-factor authentication, stronger passwords, and other security enhancements. While these additional measures improve the security posture of hospitals and make breaches less likely to occur in the future, they can also impede clinicians.

“Over the past few years, overall improvements in AMI treatment have resulted in the 30‐day AMI mortality rate decreasing about 0.4 percentage points annually from 2012 to 2014,” wrote the researchers. “A 0.23‐0.36 percentage point increase in 30‐day AMI mortality rate after a breach effectively erases a year’s worth of improvement in the mortality rate.”

The researchers suggest hospitals should carefully evaluate the security measures they implement to prevent further breaches to ensure they do not unduly impede clinicians and negatively affect patient outcomes.

The study – Data breach remediation efforts and their implications for hospital quality – was published in the October edition of Health Services Research: DOI: 10.1111/1475-6773.13203.

The post Report Suggests Augmented Security Following a Data Breach Contributes to Increase in Patient Mortality Rate appeared first on HIPAA Journal.